Not all feathers are suitable for making quill pens - they must be hollow to hold the ink, and large enough to handle, so generally the flight feathers are used. The natural curve of the feather's shaft means that feathers from the left wing are chosen for right-handers, from the right wing for left-handers. (Though of course, historically, left-handers had their 'evil' tendencies beaten out of them, forced to scrawl with their right hand.) The flamboyant feathery objects you see in movies aren't historically accurate - most of the fletching is removed from the quill to facilitate a good grip.

